Part 2 of the “Towel-Bearers: Redefining Leadership” Series

Not everyone with a Bible and a microphone should be leading people.
Yeah, there are counterfeit leaders in the Church. And they’re not always easy to spot. They sound holy. They know the lingo. They wear the “right” clothes. They inspire crowds, cast vision, and quote Scripture on demand. But behind the scenes, it’s not about Jesus—it’s about their own control, ego, and power.
Jesus warned us: “Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves.”(Matthew 7:15, ESV)
We should’ve been listening.
4 Signs of a Counterfeit Leader
1. People Are Used, Not Shepherded
Counterfeit leaders don’t build people up—they use them to build their platform. If you’re only celebrated when you’re useful, and ghosted when you’re not, you’re not being pastored. You’re being leveraged.
Servant-hearted leaders walk with you—especially when you can’t offer anything in return.
2. Disagreement Is Punished, Not Processed
Try questioning their decision. Watch what happens.
If the response is silence, guilt-tripping, or spiritual intimidation (“Touch not the Lord’s anointed!”), that’s not leadership. That’s dictatorship in a title or position.
Jesus welcomed correction, modeled vulnerability, and still stooped to wash His disciples’ feet.
3. Fear Replaces Freedom
If you constantly feel anxious around your leader—like any wrong move will cost you your place—you’re not under godly authority. You’re under human control.
Jesus sets people free. Leadership that leads with fear doesn’t come from Him.
4. Their Private Life Doesn’t Match Their Platform
This is the hardest one. You don’t always see it right away. But true leadership shows up in the home, in the staff culture, in the way they treat the least powerful around them.
If their public presence is polished but the people closest to them are walking on eggshells—pay attention.
There’s Grace for This
Maybe this stings because you’ve followed a counterfeit leader.
Maybe it stings more because you’ve been (or are) one.
There’s grace. There’s always grace. But grace doesn’t mean silence. And it doesn’t mean ignoring the pain of those who’ve been hurt in the name of “leadership.”
You’re not crazy. You’re not bitter. You’re just waking up.
The Call: Watch for Fruit, Not Flash
We need leaders who bleed love, not demand loyalty.
Who show up in silence, not just in the spotlight.
Who carry towels, not just sit on their personal thrones.
Don’t settle for stage lights. Look for the ones who stay when the lights go out.
Want more?
Stay tuned for Part 3 of our Towel-Bearers series:
“The Weight of the Towel: When Serving Hurts” — how to lead with a servant’s heart when your soul is tired.